If you read the title of this blog post and are thinking, "10 Gbps on a Pi? You're nuts!," well, check out my video on using the ASUS XG-C100C 10G NIC on the Raspberry Pi CM4. Back? Good.
To be clear: it's impossible to route 10 gigabits of total network throughput through any Raspberry Pi on the market today.
But it is possible to connect to a 10 gigabit network at 10GBase-T speeds using a Raspberry Pi Compute Module 4 and an appropriate PCI Express 10G NIC. And on my Pi PCI Express site, I documented exactly how I got an ASUS XG-C100C working on the Raspberry Pi. All it takes is a quick recompile of the kernel, and away it goes!
But this blog post isn't about how I got the card working, or about 10 gigabit networking in general. I want to cover optimizations you can make to take a Raspberry Pi from 3 Gbps to 3.6 Gbps!
If you think trying to increase not-10-gigabit to still-not-10-gigabit speeds is dumb and I'm an idiot for trying this stuff on a Raspberry Pi and not [your platform of choice], the back button is just a few centimeters away from here, go click it 😉
For the ASUS card I tested, overclocking the Pi's CPU (defaulted to 1.5 GHz) didn't actually make much of a difference, since the CPU was not the limiting factor for processing network packets. The NIC does a good job offloading that task.
But for many NICs, they don't, and having the CPU run faster means it can handle more packet throughput, allowing you to get more bandwidth. (You can use
atop to measure if your NIC is CPU-throttled—run it during an
iperf3 test and see if IRQ interrupts turn red at 98-99%).
To overclock a Pi, it's pretty simple; edit
/boot/config.txt and add the following lines:
Reboot, and the Pi is now a 2.0 GHz Pi. Higher values are possible, but with 99% of Pis out there, a 2.0 GHz clock is as high as I go to keep stability without specialized cooling.
PCI Express hierarchy optimization
I have to be honest, I am basically a beginner-level practitioner of the PCI Express protocol. But after a recommendation from NickMihailov on GitHub, I added the following kernel parameter before
rootwait in my
/boot/cmdline.txt and rebooted:
This option set's the Linux device's MPS (Max Payload Size) to the largest possible value based on the Pi's PCI Express bus. The maximum on the Pi is 512 bytes—and checking before setting this option, I could see the card was registering at 128 bytes.
The lower setting is good for compatibility, or if you have multiple PCI Express devices and need features like hotplug and peer-to-peer DMA, but for the highest speed, it's better to have a larger payload size so you can fit more data in fewer packets through the bus.
I tested with and without this option enabled, and went from
3.02 Gbps with it disabled (128 bytes) to 3.42 Gbps with it enabled (512 bytes). That's a 12% speedup!
Jumbo frames are basically Ethernet frames with a larger 'payload' size. It's like switching your data packets from little 'Smart Car' sized vehicles to 18-wheeler trailers. You can put 9000 bytes of data into jumbo frame packets, while only 1500 bytes go into a standard frame. (This number is often referred to as 'MTU', or 'Maximum Transmission Unit', so you'd say a Jumbo frame has 9000 MTU.)
The Pi's internal Ethernet interface requires a kernel recompile to change the MTU from the default, but external NICs are typically happy to let you assign whatever MTU you want (within reason).
To set it for the ASUS NIC, I ran the following command:
sudo ifconfig eth1 mtu 9000 up
The major caveat? Anything else between your NIC and the NIC you want to communicate with also has to have jumbo frames enabled. On a tightly-controlled LAN with good equipment, it's not a big issue. But over larger networks, or if you don't really know what you're doing, it's best to stick to the normal 1500 MTU setting.
With Jumbo Frames and the PCI Express optimization mentioned previously, I can get 3.59 Gbps between my Mac and the Pi.
In total, those two optimizations made the maximum network speed almost 20% faster!
The Raspberry Pi's current built-in NIC gets you a pretty solid 943 Mbps over a 1GBase-T network. For most people, that's fine. Some of these optimizations (most notably 9000 MTU / Jumbo Frames) will push that beyond 960 Mbps, but it's not a huge difference.
It's nice to know that even current-generation Pis can benefit from 2.5G and 5G networking, especially since (at least for 2.5G) newer network gear and inexpensive NICs allows a pretty much free doubling of speed using existing cabling (assuming you're already using Cat5e or better).
And maybe a newer generation Pi 5 could allow us to tap into more PCI Express lanes at a faster rate, and make it so Pis can be first-class citizens on a 10 gigabit network!
Nice research, interesting read and no I don't think you're an idiot for trying this lol. The question is when will 10G NIC in RPi be ready for production. I wonder just how long it will last at continuous 3Gbps throughput considering overclocking etc. I suppose with enough cooling everything should be fine. Keep it up, great read!
10 gbps card in a 5 gbps slot. you're insane... (more than red shirt jeff)
Raspberry PI CM4 has a PCI Express 2.0 x 1 slot which has a maximum throughput of 500mb/sec. 512*8 = 4096mbit/s. Obviously there is overhead in processing ethernet packets/frames so I'm not surprised you can get a max of 3.59gbit/s.
Assuming they up the spec of the Pi CM5 or whatever it is to be called to PCI Express 3.0. This has double the throughput per lane of PCI Express 2.0. So even if they implement just a single lane, it'll be capable of a maximum throughput of 1000mb/sec or 8192mbit/s. ie. 8gbit/sec. Again with processing of ethernet packets/frame overhead I'd guess around 7-7.5gbit/s ;-)
How many PCI Express 3.0 Lanes can the rumoured Quad-core Cortex-A76 (ARM v8.2) 64-bit SoC handle?